Molly Shannon

Emily Dickinson

Susan Ziegler

Susan Dickinson

Amy Seimetz

Mabel Todd

Brett Gelman

Col. Thomas Wentworth Higginson

Jackie Monahan

Lavina Dickinson

Kevin Seal

Austin Dickinson

Dana Melanie

Young Emily

Sasha Frolova

Young Susan

Lisa Haas

Maggie

Stella Chestnut

Mattie Dickinson

Guinevere Turner

Elizabeth Holland

Michael Churven

Josiah Holland

Robert McCaskill

Ralph Waldo Emerson

Lauren Modiano

Adult Mattie Dickinson

Al Sutton

Judge Lord

John Peña Griswold

Young Austin

Allison Lane

The Widow Kate

Margot Kistler

Young Lavinia