Rob LaColla Jr.

David Kinney, Detective Frazier

Jarod Lindsey

Jasper Perry

Vic Noto

Murderer Harold Bennett

Keith Whitler

Self - Det., Evansville IN Police Department, Self - Det., Evansville IN Police Department (ret.)

Sara Hooe

Self - Crime Scene Officer, Evansville IN Police Department, Self - Crime Scene Ofc., Evansville IN Police Department

Keith Kopcha

Self - Det.Lt., Milwaukee WI Police Department (ret.), Self - Det., Milwaukee WI Police Department

Jason Simpkins

Self - Det., Blytheville AR Police Department

Zaire O'Neal

Self - Anthony's Sister

Aaron Bourland

Self - Det., Evansville IN Police Department (ret.)

Brent Melton

Self - Det., Evansville IN Police Department (ret.)

Rachel Discenza-Smith

Self - Det., Farmington NM Police Department

Rick Staly

Self - Sheriff, Flagler County FL

Greg Touchberry

Self - Lt., Columbus GA Police Department

Tony Starvaggi

Self - Det. Sgt., Akron OH Police Department

Abbey Dubin

Detective Jenny Belluccia

Dave DeAndrea

Narrator