Melissa Leo

Madalyn Murray O'Hair

Brandon Mychal Smith

Roy Collier

Juno Temple

Robin

Michael Chernus

Garth

Rory Cochrane

Gary Karr

Alex Frost

Danny Fry

José Zúñiga

Detective Campos

Josh Lucas

David Waters

Vincent Kartheiser

Bill, Jr

Adam Scott

Jack Ferguson

Marco Sanchez

Frank Gonzalez

Andy Walken

Young Bill

Ryan Cutrona

Pup

Sally Kirkland

Lena

Devin Freeman

Teen Bill, Jr

Anna Camp

Mrs. Lutz

Ward Roberts

Radio Announcer

Devin Barry

Jesus Freak