Lindsay Lohan

Avery

Ian Harding

Logan

Kristin Chenoweth

Erica

Jon Rudnitsky

Cameron

Katie Baker

Cassie

Jake Brennan

Callum

Dan Bucatinsky

Leonard

Tim Meadows

Stan

Judy Reyes

Margaret

Ash Santos

Sophie

Henry Czerny

Mitchell

Bobbie Eakes

Cheryl

Melinda Tanner

Ida

Mim Drew

Susan

Chris Parnell

Veterinarian

Kurt Yue

Priest

Nathan Tutterrow

Altar Boy

Jade Fernandez

Holly