Rod Serling

Self - Host, Writer

Joanna Pettet

Elaine Latimer (segment "The House"), Rhona Warwick (segment "The Caterpillar")

Gary Collins

Dr. Michael Rhodes

Susan Strasberg

Ruth Asquith (segment "Midnight Never Ends"), Sheila Trent

Geraldine Page

Frances Turchin (segment "Stop Killing Me"), Molly Wheatland, Mrs. Evans (segment "The Sins of the Fathers")

John Astin

Jonathan (segment "Pamela's Voice"), Munsch, Randy Miller (segment "Hell's Bells")

Alan Napier

Cousin Zachariah Ogilvy, Doctor (segment "House - With Ghost"), The Man (segment "The Sins of the Fathers")

John J. Fox

Heckler (segment "Make Me Laugh"), Mr. Tourist (segment "Hell's Bells"), Santa Claus (segment "The Messiah on Mott Street")

John Barclay

Another Man (segment "The Sins of the Fathers"), Butler (segment "The Doll"), William Sharsted Sr. (segment "Camera Obscura")

Sandra Dee

Alice Martin, Ann Bolt (segment "Tell David..."), Marion Hardy

Jason Wingreen

2nd Reporter (segment "The Nature of the Enemy"), Doctor (segment "Silent Snow, Secret Snow"), Dr. Morris Wilbur

Ross Martin

Bradley Meredith, Mr. Gingold (segment "Camera Obscura")

Stuart Whitman

Capt. Hendrick Lindemann (segment "Lindemann's Catch"), Tom Ogilvy

William Windom

Professor Putman (segment "Little Girl Lost")

Larry Watson

First Deputy (segment "Green Fingers"), Kid Max (segment "The Waiting Room"), Longhair

Michael Laird

Joel Robb (segment "The Dark Boy"), Michael, 1st Goblin

Jack Laird

Laboratory Assistant (segment "With Apologies to Mr. Hyde"), Igor (segment "The Funeral"), Second Demon (segment "Hell's Bells")

Matt Pelto

2nd Doctor (segment "The Little Black Bag"), Bartleby the Undertaker, 2nd Workman (segment "They're Tearing Down Tim Riley's Bar")