Chloë Sevigny

Lizzie Borden

Kristen Stewart

Bridget Sullivan

Jeff Perry

Andrew Jennings

Fiona Shaw

Abby Borden

Jamey Sheridan

Andrew Borden

Tara Ochs

Susan Gilbert

Kim Dickens

Emma Borden

Daniel Wachs

Dr. Bowen

Denis O'Hare

John Morse

Jody Matzer

Deputy Fleet

Don Henderson Baker

Marshall Hilliard

Jay Huguley

William Henry Moody

Roscoe Sandlin

Judge Blaisdell

Tom Thon

Professor Wood

Katharine Harrington

Matron

Darin Cooper

Jury Foreman

Laura Whyte

Mrs. Brayton

Vivian Majkowski

New Housemaid