Joe Berlinger

Self - Documentary Filmmaker

Angela Clemente

Self - Forensic Intelligence Analyst

Steve Bongardt

Self - Criminal Profiler

George W. Lavender Jr.

Self - Sheriff Ross County, OH

Bud Lytle

Self - Chillicothe Police Dept, Self - Chillicothe Police Dept.

Mike Throne

Self - Editor, Chillicothe Gazette

Yvonne Boggs

Self - Charlotte's Mother

Angela Robinson

Self - Tameka's Mother

John Gabis

Self - Ross County Coroner

Wallace Coleman

Self - Former Associate of Dollar Bill

Sam Sayre

Self - Tiffany's Aunt

Ruth Sayre

Self - Tiffany's Grandmother

Jessie Sanford

Self - Tiffany's Friend

Jason McCrary

Self - Murder Defendant

Kendra Dutchess

Self - Shasta's Friend

Jon Winfield

Self - Ross County Sheriff's Dept.

Robin Kellough

Self - Megan's Mother

Jessica Lowry

Self - Witness