Keith David

Self - Narrator

Hugo Holland

Self - Louisiana Special Prosecutor, Self - Special Prosecutor

Cheryl Lieck

Self - Chambers County District Attorney

William Reece

Self

Kathryn Casey

Self - True Crime Author

Jeanie Escamilla

Self - Krystal's Mother

Brian Hawthorne

Self - Chambers County Sheriff

Krystal Baker

Self - Murder Victim

Kevin Edison Smith

Self - Confessed Killer

Brad Goetschius

Self - Former Detective, Texas City Police Department

Brad Moon

Self - Former Investigator, Chambers County Sheriff's Office

Aubrey St. Angelo

Self - Detective, Iberville Parish

Ronnie Hebert

Self - Chief Criminal Deputy, Iberville Parish

Shay Randle

Self - Former Reporter, The Daily Advertiser

George Schiro Jr.

Self - Director, Scales Biological Laboratory

Woody Overton

Self - Investigative Consultant

David Anthony Burns

Self - Convicted Murderer

Jezale Carter

Self - Bonnie's Granddaughter