Andrew Wall

Narrator

Corey Rademaker

Anton Schuessler Sr, Kenyon Battles Tolerton, Mike

Morgan Easton-Fitzgerald

Christine Jessop, Danelle Lietz, Heather

Glen Spryszak

Self

Dean Pritchard

Self

Chelsea Suderman

Self

Derek Steele

Cold Case Detective, Dad Wood

Todd Picklyk

Kenneth Hansen

Luigi Imbrogno

Detective Rice, Forensic Officer, Officer #3

Hank Koreman

Detective Joe Dunn

David Sinkarsin

Eric Schubert

Chris Parsons

Byron Wright, Henry Lee Lucas