Jennifer Love Hewitt

Self - Narrator

Connor Rush

Self - Trent Digiuro, Self - Buck Blodgett

James Zywicki

Self - Investigator Hartford PD, Self - Inspector, Self - Lieutenant Zywicki

Isabel Jara

Self - Jesse

Jessie Blodgett

Self

Pat Pemberton

Self - Local Reporter

Elyse Marie Pahler

Self

Trent DiGiuro

Self - Victim

Kevin Carson

Self - Brother of Michele

Royce Casey

Self - Convicted Murder

Buck Blodgett

Self - Jessie's Dad

Shane Ragland

Self

Esther Deleon

Self - Mother of Michele

John Carson

Self - Father of Michele

Alexander Slack

Self - Royce Elliot Casey

David Pahler

Self - Elyse's Father

Jacob Delashmutt

Self - Convicted Murder