Nicole Eggert

Lisa

David O'Donnell

Rick

Tom Arnold

Malone

David DeLuise

Andy

Shannon Sturges

Cassidy

Sarah Thompson

Reagan

Patty McCormack

Maggie

John Colton

Harry

Timothy Oman

Wayne

Caia Coley

Annie

Beth Shea

Rosemary

Abby Box

Caroler

Joshua Chelmo

Waiter

Jody Cosgrove-Kao

Church Attendee

David Hill

Barn Dance Partyer

Mike Korich

Sheriff Carlson

Mary Morales

Caroler